In November of 1995, I received a letter from a reader,
Alyson, who asked if I’d write a book about relationship abuse between
lesbians. She’d lived through the experience herself and felt that same-sex
abuse was an important topic—one that wasn’t represented in young adult
literature. I told her what I always tell people who make specific requests
for books: “This is your story and I think you should tell it.” Everyone’s
experience is unique to them, and even though I’ve written stories in the
past that I haven’t lived through, (i.e. Luna),
I don’t believe I can write authentically about any topic in the world. Also,
at the time, I was working on two or three other books. Alyson wrote back. She said even if she did write the story,
it wouldn’t reach as many people as my book might, or have the impact. I told
her, as kindly as possible, that I really didn’t want to write a book about
abuse. Why? Well, for one thing, the books I’ve read about relationship
abuse always include a villain and a victim. I don’t believe that’s the case.
Where there’s a dysfunctional relationship both parties contribute. I knew
violence was about control, and most probably a learned behavior from
childhood, but a person who takes it and keeps taking it must have a need to
be controlled somehow. I’d never explored in depth what that need was, and I
wasn’t sure I wanted to. I think I actually had a sympathetic bias in favor
of the abuser. Alyson wrote back again and again. Each time, she asked,
“Have you given any more thought to the book?” I told her, “I really don’t
want to write it, Alyson. I don’t know that much about lesbian abuse.” She
said, “I have all my journals and diaries. You’re free to use them. And I’ll answer
any questions you have.” This girl was persistent. She was making it very
difficult to say no. I learned she and her girlfriend had begun their abusive
relationship in high school—a truly violent one—and continued it after
graduation. Fortunately, they both got counseling and the violence ended. But I had another bias. I wasn’t sure people who lived
through abusive relationships ever came out whole. The couple may resolve the
immediate issue, but there’s still an underlying monster that keeps them together
for the wrong reasons. Was I wrong? I’m no psychologist, so it was only my
gut reaction. Alyson wrote me month after month. We became friends. She
and her girlfriend were doing well, building a life together. Then suddenly
all communication stopped. I worried about her. I wrote and wrote to her. Finally, I
received an email and she said she and her girlfriend had broken up, that it
just wasn’t going to work. At that point I felt I could write this book. Maybe it
was my investment in Alyson and her welfare, or my growing interest in the
topic of same-sex abuse. Perhaps it was timing. My story wouldn’t be
Alyson’s, of course, but I could bring my own sensibilities to it. Alyson was extremely supportive throughout the research
and writing phases, which were lengthy. I’m grateful to her for her honesty,
courage, openness and detailed critique of the manuscript. I’m thankful she
encouraged me to educate myself and others on the realities of partner abuse
among lesbians. Yes, it reflects the same realities as heterosexual abuse,
but there are also important differences:
Abuse manifests in a number of ways. The violence can be
overt, such as punching, hitting, kicking, pushing or shoving. It can include
forced participation in sex or withholding sex. Abuse can be covert as well. “I’ll out you if you say
anything,” is an example of psychological manipulation. Girls may also feel
isolated and humiliated by their situation. When a person is under the control of another, it
undermines her self-esteem. Abusive situations are devastating to a young
woman’s sense of herself and her ability to make informed choices. If you suspect you are in an abusive relationship (and
sometimes you don’t even realize it), there are steps you can take:
Remember:
|
Privacy Statement
In compliance with the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA)
no personal information on visitors is collected or shared.
Web site Copyright © 2000-2010 by Julie Anne
Peters
All Rights Reserved